The first theoretical model of magnetic
reconnection was that of Sweet-Parker. In this theory the breaking of
the frozen-in condition that facilitates the topological change in the
magnetic field required for reconnection occurs in a macroscopic
current layer called the dissipation region. The high elongation of
this current layer (the width being controlled by the small plasma
resistivity) combined with inflow-outflow continuity yields rates of
flux annihilation that scale like sqrt(eta). For classical values
of the resistivity this rate of reconnection is far smaller than that
inferred from observations in both astrophysical and laboratory
systems. The Petschek theory of reconnection, in which the dissipation
region is spatially localized, yields high rates of
reconnection. Computer simulations demonstrated that the Sweet-Parker
structure of the dissipation region predominates in systems with
uniform resistivity. The predominance of such
elongated layers was shown to be a consequence of the singular
behavior of post-reconnection equilibria.
Two models for boosting the Sweet-Parker rates of reconnection have
found support from computation and observational data: the kinetic
reconnection model and the anomalous resistivity model. In the kinetic
reconnection model fast reconnection is facilitated by the coupling to
non-MHD, dispersive waves at the small spatial scales that
characterize the dissipation region. These waves shorten the
elongated Sweet-Parker current layer into a Petschek-like open
X-line configuration with its characteristic fast rate of
reconnection. Both dedicated laboratory reconnection experiments as
well as satellite observations have provided evidence for the coupling
to these dispersive waves.
The anomalous resistivity hypothesis dates from the early 1960's. The
suggestion was that the large relative streaming between electron and
ions, a consequence of the strong current present in the dissipation
region, would drive turbulence that could cause scattering and thereby
enhance the drag between electrons and ions, e.g., an enhanced
and therefore ``anomalous'' resistivity. Anomalous resistivity has
been widely invoked over the past four decades to justify the
resistive MHD description of magnetic reconnection in nature. However,
the theoretical underpining for the idea has remained weak. There is
observational evidence for the presence of turbulence in laboratory
reconnection experiments, measurements of sawteeth in tokamaks and in
the Earth's magnetosphere. The strongest evidence in favor of the
anomalous resistivity hypothesis has come from recent measurement of
magnetic fluctuations on the MRX experiment and the widespread
identification of ``electron holes'' in boundary layers of the Earth's
magnetosphere where reconnection is expected to be active. 3-D
particle simulations of magnetic reconnection are now for the first
time able to address the anomalous resistivity problem and have
demonstrated that electron-hole formation and associated anomalous
resistivity are a natural consequence of reconnection in high
temperature plasma.
While evidence is now substantial that anomalous resistivity may be
active during reconnection, we are far from having a comprehensive
understanding of the detailed mechanisms sufficient to model the
effect in nearly collisionless systems such as tokamaks where
reconnection electric fields can exceed the Dreicer runaway field
during sawteeth and disruptions. To address this question we propose a
program with three linked elements. The first is a comprehensive set
of laboratory experiments to be carried out on the LAPD device at UCLA
to explore the development of electron-ion streaming instabilities and
associated heating and anomalous resistivity. The second element is
turbulence measurements during reconnection on VTF at MIT. In the
third element, parallel 3-D particle simulations with the p3d
code will be carried out and the results compared with the
experimental measurements. The relative roles of the ion acoustic
instability, which can be driven unstable when Te >>
Ti, the Buneman instability and off-angle lower-hybrid
modes will be explored. Questions such as the following will be
addressed. Can the ion acoustic instability halt the runaway of
electrons or does the system evolve into the stronger Buneman unstable
configuration and develop electron holes as a nonlinear state? Since
the instabilities causing the anomalous resistivity have rapid
timescales compared to the reconnection time a multiscale
simplification is desirable. For example, theoretical scaling laws for
the turbulence and associated resistivity will be developed for
implementation in large scale reconnection models. A more ambitious
approach involving coupling fast time-scale codes calculating the
average effect of the turbulence to slow time-scale codes calculating
the reconnection itself is also being developed.
Detailed research plans: LAPD and
VTF
|